Daniel Naroditsky

Edward Winter



daniel naroditsky

See the item dated 21 October 2025 below.



We begin with two items (C.N.s 7071 and 7087) contributed by Daniel Naroditsky in May 2011, when he was aged 15.


Daniel Naroditsky (Foster City, CA, USA) notes a number of failings in the Chess School series of books published by the Russian Chess House. The present item quotes his comments on three positions from Chess School 3 The Manual of Chess Combinations by Alexander Mazja (Moscow, 2003):

1) Page 77 (position 371): Lipnitsky v Smyslov, Moscow, 1950 (variation):

dia

‘The book’s solution is 1 Nxe4 dxe4 2 Ra2 Bb4+ 3 Kd1 Qxa2 4 Bxa2 exd3 5 axb4 Rfd8 6 Ne5 Nxb4 7 Bb1 and “White stands slightly better”.

First of all, 1 Nxe4, to which the book awards an exclamation mark, is by no means better than the simple 1 Nxf8, which leads to an advantageous position after 1…Qxf2+ 2 Kd1. In addition, 6 Ne5 and 7 Bb1 are both erroneous, squandering White’s sizable advantage. Instead, 6 Nc5, attacking b7 as well as d3, is much better, and the passive 7 Bb1 in the solution should be replaced by 7 Bc4, preventing 7…f6.’

2) Page 78 (position 373): Evdokimov v Ragozin, ‘SSSR, 1955’:

dia

‘The solution (which was the play in the actual game) is given as: 1…Qe2 2 Qxb5 Ne3+ 3 Kc3 Rxc5+ 4 bxc5 Nd5+ 5 Kd4 Qg4+ 6 Kxd5 Bxd3 7 Qa4 Rd8+ and wins. However, a much quicker way to win is 6…Be6+ 7 Kc6 Qf3+ 8 Be4 Qxe4+ 9 Kxc7 Rc8+ 10 Kd6 Qd5+ 11 Ke7 Qd8 mate.’

3) Page 79 (position 384): Fairhurst v Kashdan, ‘Folkstown’ [Folkestone], 1933:

dia

‘The solution is given in the book as:

chess

chess

The absence of signs for captures and for check exacerbates the problem. The solution is nonsense, with ‘...fe’ given twice. The move 1…fxe6 is wrong, as White wins after 2 Qxe6+ Be7 3 Re1 with a deadly attack.’

We add below the relevant part of Kashdan’s own annotations, on page 15 of the Book of the Folkestone 1933 International Chess Team Tournament (Leeds, 1933):

chess

(7071)

Daniel Naroditsky offers some examples of errors in another tome in the series, Chess School 2 The Manual of Chess Combinations by Sergey Ivashchenko (Moscow, 2002):

1) Page 129 (position 709): ‘Agatov v Kurmashov, Kaliningrad, 1978’:

dia

‘The solution is given as 1…a3 2 Nc1 Ba4 3 Kxd5 Bb3 4 cxb3 a2 5 Nxa2 cxb3 and “Black has a decisive advantage”.

First of all, 3 dxc4 instead of 3 Kxd5 gives White a clear advantage after 3…dxc4 4 Kxc4 followed by 5 Kb4. Secondly, 4 dxc4 too is strong and also gives White a clear advantage (i.e. 4…Bxc2 5 Kd4 and 6 Kc3). Finally, 4…a2 is obviously horrible. 4…cxd3 is the winning move, when White cannot stop Black’s pawns. After 6 Nc3 White has an elementary win.

The simple explanation is that the diagram is wrong; the white pawn should be on c3, not d3. The correct position is given in various endgame books, a recent example being page 412 of Endgame Tactics by G.C. van Perlo (Alkmaar, 2006), which states “Agapov-Kurmasov, Soviet Union, 1978”.’

2) Page 150 (position 831): Averbakh v Bondarevsky, ‘USSR, 1961’:

dia

‘In the book the solution is given as 1 Bxh6 Bxh6 2 Qxh6+ Kxh6 3 Rg6+ Kxh5 4 Nxe5+, etc.

4 R1g5 mate is missed, and there is no mention of the line 3…Bxg6 4 Rxg6+ Kh5 5 Nxe5+ Ng4 6 Bxg4+ Kh4 7 Rh6+ Kg5 8 Nxf7+ Kxg4 9 Nxd8, as given on page 71 of Averbakh’s Selected Games (London, 1998):

averbakh

In Ivashchenko’s book the game is misdated 1961 (it was played in the USSR Championship in Moscow in 1951), and it is not specified that the position did not occur in the actual game.’

3) Page 151 (position 840): Foltys v Golombek, ‘Prague, 1947’:

dia

‘The game was played not in Prague but in London (in a match between Great Britain and Czechoslovakia). According to the book, the solution is 1 Rxa6 Rxa6 2 Rb7 Rg7 3 c7 Ra8 4 Rb8 Rg8 5 Rxa8 Rxa8 6 Nd7+ Ke7 7 Nb8. But, of course, 7…Ra1+ followed by 8…Rc1 wins outright. The explanation is that a white pawn is missing in the diagram position. In the actual game Black resigned after the rook capture on a8.’

4) Page 183 (position 1025): ‘Crowl v Fehl, 1962’:

dia

‘According to Ivashchenko, the solution is 1 Qxb7+ Kxb7 2 c6+ Ka8 3 c7 Kb7 4 Ba6+ Kxa6 5 c8(Q)+ Kxa5 6 Qc6 a6 7 Kb3 Nd7 8 Qc7+ Nb6 9 Qc3+.

However, after 6…Qh2+ 7 Kb3 Qe2, there is no mate in sight, and White has to settle for perpetual check. In the starting position, the simple 1 Ba6 bxa6 2 Qc6 leads to a quick mate.’

(7087)



From Chess Records, on the subject of the young chess authors:

John Donaldson (Berkeley, CA, USA) points out that a volume by Daniel Naroditsky is due to be published by New in Chess in 2010. Its title is Mastering Positional Chess: Practical Lessons of a Junior World Champion.

We are also grateful to Mr Donaldson for obtaining from Vladimir Naroditsky his son’s birth-date: 9 November 1995.

(6310)

The book was published in March 2010:

naroditsky



From an addition dated 29 September 2023 to Chess Broadcasts on the Internet:

A name today that will surely be on the list of almost everyone’s favourite chess broadcasters is Daniel Naroditsky, given his combination of acumen and eloquence.

From C.N. 12271:

C.N. 9085 gave our choice of the five best online chess hosts/presenters in English. Eleven years on, a new list is now offered (in alphabetical order): Jan Gustafsson, Jovanka Houska, Yasser Seirawan and Peter Svidler. How we wish that a fifth name could be added: Daniel Naroditsky.



On 20 October 2025 it was announced that Daniel Naroditsky had died. He was 29.



Addition on 21 October 2025:

daniel naroditsky

The conclusion of an interview with Daniel Naroditsky in the New York Times, 12 June 2022:

‘To emphasize the fact that he speaks to players of all levels, Mr Naroditsky said that his favorite quote about chess was one best known as an Italian proverb but most likely traceable to a 1629 collection of writings by John Boys, who was the Dean of Canterbury in England:

“At the end of the game, both the king and the pawn go into the same box.”’

A Quote Investigator page discusses that chess metaphor in The Workes of Iohn Boys (London, 1629), and we see that it had also appeared on page 129 of the London, 1622 edition:

naroditsky favourite chess quotation



Addition on 22 October 2025:

Where online are Daniel Naroditsky’s finest games the focus of attention?



Additions on 24 October 2025:

Leonard Barden has marked the death of Daniel Naroditsky with an outstanding article (Guardian, 24 October 2025).

leonard barden vladimir kramnik daniel naroditsky



A YouTube video of Daniel Naroditsky in conversation with Cristian Chirila and Fabiano Caruana is recommended. It was posted on 26 September 2023.

Starting at 01:02:39, Naroditsky says:

‘I am by nature a very private person. I’m an introvert, some people might be surprised to find. I’m very much an introvert, and I do like my peace and quiet.’

Further quotes:

00:10:48: ‘I am extremely shy and I don’t want to attract any attention to myself.’

00:14:52: ‘I always had confidence issues as a kid and I still struggle with that, but as a kid it was really debilitating.’

00:58.12: ‘I love chess more than I’ve ever loved it in my life.’



Additions on 25 October 2025:

The conclusion of the personal dedications in Daniel Naroditsky’s two books:

daniel naroditsky dedication to edward winter

daniel naroditsky dedication to edward winter


‘Rowson offers an analysis of chess psychology and chess thinking that, in both depth and practical value, is unequalled in all of chess literature.’

Source: Daniel Naroditsky, Chess Life, November 2018, page 48. The reference is to Jonathan Rowson’s book Chess for Zebras (London, 2005).

See also Chess and Psychology.



Addition on 27 October 2025:

In his Financial Times chess column of 27 October 2025 Leonard Barden writes a fine appreciation of Daniel Naroditsky.

naroditsky barden

One brief remark of Mr Barden’s is extracted here:

‘As a chess teacher and communicator, Naroditsky was supremely gifted.’



Daniel Naroditsky was an infrequent but fine writer on chess. Those less gifted, or whose native language is not English, can lessen the gulf if, for every text, they systematically embrace the freely available fact-checkers, grammar-checkers and spell-checkers, the ever-improving automatic translators, AI tools employed critically, and a second opinion from qualified confidants via e-mail. That is our diplomatic, impersonal wording. A more direct formulation would be that, and still referring only to linguistic standards and clarity of presentation, much of what Vladimir Kramnik has posted on X/Twitter and elsewhere has been execrable and continues to do his cause a marked disservice.

Our feature article on Daniel Naroditsky shows the conclusion of an inscription in his first chess book – the work of a prodigy and as such a record-breaking publication. The inscription itself is private, but we dwell on the date: 9 April 2010. It is a crushing thought that nearly half of his life had already gone.

(12236)



Further to C.N. 12236.

On page 5 of the November 2025 CHESS, an editorial by Malcolm Pein observes that there was ‘an outpouring of anger’ at the first of two messages on X/Twitter posted by Emil Sutovsky, the Chief Executive Officer of FIDE, after the death of Daniel Naroditsky.

As in C.N. 12236, we propose to focus on language, and from the same standpoint: why would the CEO of a world federation issue a statement left unchecked by basic computer tools? For example, Mr Sutovsky wrote incoherently:

‘It kept haunting him for more than a year, even if there was not much of polemics of recent.’

Another faulty text:

‘... public debate within the chess world has too often moved beyond the boundaries of acceptable, harming not only people’s reputation but ...’

‘The boundaries of acceptable’?

That line comes from a statement by the President of FIDE, Arkady Dvorkovich, dated 22 October 2025, the same day as Emil Sutovsky’s two X/Twitter posts. The President announced that ‘all relevant public statements’ by Vladimir Kramnik were being referred ‘to the FIDE Ethics and Disciplinary Commission for independent consideration’.

On or about 28 October 2025, a statement appeared from the ‘Chairwoman, Ethics & Disciplinary Commission’, Yolander Persaud. One paragraph reads:

‘I confirm receipt of, and I have read the numerous email petitions made to the EDC concerning the bullying campaign and alleged unfounded cheating claims directed at GM Naroditsky, even posthumously. I acknowledge your expressions of hurt and frustration.’

Incorrect punctuation aside, there is this to consider:

‘... concerning the bullying campaign and alleged unfounded cheating claims ...’

As that text stands, the ‘Chairwoman, Ethics & Disciplinary Commission’ is publicly affirming that there was indeed a ‘bullying campaign’. Many will say, ‘Of course there was’, but where does her declaration leave Vladimir Kramnik’s entitlement, before her Commission, to deny any bullying campaign?

On the other hand, the cheating claims are described by Yolander Persaud as ‘alleged unfounded’, which has no meaning.

What could have been intended? Has she decided, with or without her Commission, that the claims about cheating were alleged and unfounded, or just alleged, or allegedly unfounded, or something else again? Above all, what business is it of hers to judge anything before the promised ‘independent consideration’ by her Commission has even begun? An AI tool would have suggested ‘cheating and bullying allegations’, a neutral wording which neither Vladimir Kramnik nor anyone else could reasonably contest.

Inquiries can drag on beyond the worst fears. It may soon be evident, if it is not already, that FIDE lacks the requisite independence and competence for such a major undertaking, and that an impartial outside body, such as an international investigation firm, needs to be engaged.

In the meantime, there is one practical step that FIDE officials, and not only them, could decide upon with immediate effect: no text will enter the public domain until the person or body concerned has found the short time needed to verify it properly with readily available IT tools.

Finally, our observation in C.N. 12166, dated 2 July 2025, is reiterated here:

The current battles over online cheating are a grimly undignified, barely intelligible mess with, as their hub, nothing better than X/Twitter.

There must be a better way.

(12237)

Addition on 11 November 2025:

The undated document referred to above:

fide ethics commission statement daniel naroditsky



‘28 October 2025’, exactly six months ago, is the date on a statement from ‘Yolander Persaud, Chairwoman, Ethics & Disciplinary Commission’. It includes the following:

fide ethics persaud kramnik naroditsky

As shown in C.N. 12237, posted on 5 November 2025, the first paragraph is ill-phrased and prejudicial.

Regarding the second paragraph, a so-called ‘Original statement’ contained, properly, no reference to David Llada, whose name was subsequently copy-pasted in, ungrammatically and irrelevantly, from a different FIDE case.

The earlier version concerning the Naroditsky case read:

fide
        ethics

Given that the faulty texts by Yolander Persaud were still online, in an e-mail message dated 27 February 2026 we drew the relevant C.N. material to her personal attention, asking when she intended to correct the mistakes (the ill-phrased and prejudicial remarks and the erroneous inclusion of Mr Llada’s name).

No reply – and no corrections.

(12297)



Chess Thoughts gives our overall view of the platform:

X/Twitter is a blighted battlefield where blustering snipers endlessly arm each other.



Addition on 11 November 2025:

The X/Twitter post by FIDE on 20 October 2025:

chess
        fide naroditsky

The first verb should be in the present perfect tense. The phrase ‘talented chess player, commentator, and educator’ reads flatly in a FIDE announcement, whereas it was suitably unassuming in the Naroditsky family statement from which it was copied:

family statement after the death of daniel naroditsky



From Chess Thoughts:



Addition on 10 November 2025:

chess articles by daniel naroditsky on chess.com

From a new Chess.com feature. Outstanding.



See also Vladimir Kramnik.



Addition on 20 November 2025:

Needed regarding online cheating: a check-list of Vladimir Kramnik’s 1) questions; 2) suspicions; 3) insinuations; 4) allegations; 5) accusations; 6) proof.



The first paragraph of an article by Daniel Naroditsky in his ‘The Practical Endgame’ series, on pages 50-51 of the September 2018 Chess Life:

‘A few days ago, I was absent-mindedly leafing through my copy of David Bronstein’s heralded classic Zurich 1953 when a curious endgame caught my eye. The game in question was contested in the 22nd round between Bronstein himself and Swedish Grandmaster Gideon Ståhlberg. I am in the process of collecting material for my upcoming book, so I figured that a closer look at this intriguing endgame was worth my while. The results of my analysis, which I would like to share with you in this month’s column, are monumental in both beauty and instructive value.’

Is anything known about the book described as ‘upcoming’?

(12259)



On 22 November 2025 an article by Raymond Keene entitled ‘Self-mate: suicide in chess’ featured Daniel Naroditsky:

keene misreporting that naroditsky committed suicide

‘Accident’ was the manner of death specified in the report dated 7 January 2026 by the North Carolina medical examiner, Dr James R. Lozano.



A Times tweet posted by Raymond Keene on 16 January 2013:

keene

See also Chess and Suicide.




youtube naroditsky

The above is a notable YouTube video by Daniel Naroditsky with advice on chess books to acquire and how to use them.

(12287)



Addition on 3 July 2026:

The FIDE Ethics & Disciplinary Commission has published its Decision in Case no. 12/2025 concerning alleged bullying by Vladimir Kramnik.

The former world champion has 21 days to appeal against the Decision and has announced on his X/Twitter page that he will be doing so.



Further brief observations in Daniel Naroditsky’s Chess Life column:

(12337)



‘Pawn endgames are unkind to the lazy chess player.’

Daniel Naroditsky, Chess Life, April 2018, page 47.

(12345)



Latest update: 10 November 2026.

To the Chess Notes main page.

To the Archives for other feature articles.



Copyright Edward Winter. All rights reserved.