Chess Notes by Edward Winter

Chess Notes

Edward Winter

When contacting us by e-mail, correspondents are asked to include their name and full postal address and, when providing information, to quote exact book and magazine sources. The word ‘chess’ needs to appear in the subject-line or in the message itself. There is also a form available for submitting games.

2 November 2017: C.N.s 10632-10634
3 November 2017: C.N. 10635
6 November 2017: C.N.s 10636-10638
8 November 2017: C.N.s 10639-10640
12 November 2017: C.N.s 10641-10643
14 November 2017: C.N. 10644
16 November 2017: C.N.s 10645-10646

Yasser Seirawan

A selection of feature articles:

Steinitz, Lasker, Potter and the ‘Modern School’
Dr Lasker’s Chess History
Chess Camouflage Publications
John Ruskin and Chess
Capablanca v Fine: A Missed Win

Archives (including all feature articles)

10632. Nicolas Rossolimo and judo

Hans Renette (Bierbeek, Belgium) sends this picture from page 2 of De Gooi- en Eemlander, 31 July 1947:


10633. Ray Charles

Paul Dorion (Montreal, Canada) notes on a CNN webpage a fine photograph of Ray Charles (1930-2004) with a Braille chess set.

10634. Fischer and Lombardy

In October 2017 Michael Clapham’s website Chess Book Chats (mentioned in C.N. 10089) had excellent items on Bobby Fischer and William Lombardy.

10635. A rusty nail

The present item may be read in conjunction with A Knight on K5, K6 or Q6.

A question asked by Jerry Hanken on page 15 of Chess Life, September 2005:

‘Was it Tarrasch who said a knight on d6 is like a rusty nail in the knee?’

A number of bottom-of-the-range Internet pages sourcelessly ascribe such a remark to Bogoljubow, the square occupied being given as e6/e3.

On page 58 of Chess Strategy and Tactics by Fred Reinfeld and Irving Chernev (New York, 1933) the observation appeared in quotation marks, but unattributed, in the game Bogoljubow v Réti, Mährisch-Ostrau, 1923:


Elsewhere, Anderssen and Steinitz have been named. Below, for example, is a footnote on page 112 of Chess Traps, Pitfalls, and Swindles by I.A. Horowitz and Fred Reinfeld (New York, 1954), concerning White’s move Nd6:

‘Of such powerfully posted knights the immortal Anderssen remarked, “They are like a rusty nail in your knee!”’

From page 93 of Bishop versus Knight: The Verdict by Steve Mayer (Seattle, 1997):

‘There’s an old line, generally attributed to Steinitz, that a knight at e6 is like a rusty nail in the knee.’

Another variant comes from page 87 of Reinfeld’s Great Short Games of the Chess Masters (New York, 1961), after 10 Nc6:

‘Of such knights, posted deep in the enemy’s territory, it has been truly said that they are “like a rusty nail in your knee”.’

Who can say whether Anderssen, Steinitz, Tarrasch, Bogoljubow or somebody else made such a remark about a knight on Q6, K6, QB6 or KB6 – or, indeed, whether the nail-like occupant was necessarily a knight? The annotation below is by Jack W. Collins on page 19 of the November 1947 Chess Review:

‘He has two bishops, a passed pawn at K6 (a rusty nail in the knee, according to Steinitz), and aggressively placed rooks.’

10636. An inscription by Smyslov

‘“To the world champion of Chess Literature” – such was the flattering manner in which Smyslov inscribed the book of his collected games which he presented to Harry Golombek on the day he won the world championship from Botvinnik.’

Source: page 170 of The Delights of Chess by Assiac (London, 1960). For a more specific, and less flattering, assessment, see Harry Golombek’s Book on Capablanca.

One of our copies of the 1974 Dover reprint of The Delights of Chess has a full-page signature by Tony Miles:


10637. Louis Persinger

A feature article on Louis Persinger is in preparation, based on a number of C.N. items on his involvement in chess. Richard Reich (Fitchburg, WI, USA) reports that he owns a copy of Capablanca’s Havana, 1913 tournament book signed by Persinger:


10638. Ernest Hemingway

Richard Reich asks whether any solid biographical information is available about Ernest Hemingway’s interest in chess.

10639. 16 computations a second

Further to C.N. 2646 (see Chess and Computers), the device in question was discussed on page 34 of Chess Review, February 1953, where Robert H. Dunn quoted the following:


10640. L. Verkhovsky

Siegrun Macgilchrist (Maybole, Scotland) asks for biographical information on Leonid Verkhovsky. Can readers suggest any particularly good sources?

Verkhovsky is best known for his 1972 book Nichya!; a Spanish translation, Tablas, was published the following year. A second Russian-language edition appeared in 1979; regarding the shoddy English version (Milford, 2014) see C.N. 9098.


Verkhovsky also wrote a book on Zugzwang (Moscow, 1989), and an Italian translation came out in 1992. Another work is a monograph on Schlechter (Moscow, 1984), with a Foreword by Lev Polugayevsky.

10641. Steinitz and Chigorin

How much of Fred Reinfeld’s passage below, concerning Steinitz and Chigorin, can be corroborated?


The source is Reinfeld’s book The Great Chess Masters and Their Games (subtitle: ‘The Human Side of Chess’). See pages 109-110 of the original US edition (New York, 1952) and page 113 of the UK edition (London, 1953).

10642. Capablanca games

Gerard Killoran (Ilkley, England) sends a game from page 2 of the Sunday Oregonian, 6 August 1916:


José Raúl Capablanca (simultaneous) – J.H. Smith
San Diego, 15 April 1916
Bird’s Opening

1 f4 e6 2 Nf3 d5 3 b3 b6 4 Bb2 Bb7 5 e3 Nf6 6 Be2 Bd6 7 Ne5 O-O 8 O-O Qe7 9 d3 h6 10 g3 Nh7 11 Nd2 Ba3 12 Bc3 a6 13 Ndf3 Bc5 14 Qd2 a5 15 Bb2 Ba3 16 Bxa3 Qxa3 17 g4 Qd6 18 Qe1 Nc6 19 d4 Ne7 20 Qh4 c5


21 g5 hxg5 22 fxg5 g6 23 Bd3 cxd4 24 Ng4 f5 25 Nf6+ Nxf6 26 gxf6


26...Rf7 27 fxe7 Rh7 28 Qf6 dxe3 29 Ng5 Qxh2 mate.

Our correspondent also reports that page 6 of the 16 November 1919 edition of the same newspaper had this game (bare score):

José Raúl Capablanca (simultaneous) – Charles F. Bauder
Philadelphia, 28 September 1918
Queen’s Gambit Declined

1 d4 d5 2 Nf3 Nf6 3 c4 e6 4 Nc3 c6 5 Bg5 Nbd7 6 e3 Qa5 7 Nd2 Bb4 8 Qc2 Ne4 9 Ndxe4 dxe4 10 Bh4 e5 11 Be2 O-O 12 O-O


12...f5 13 c5 Nf6 14 dxe5 Bxc3 15 bxc3 Nd5 16 c4 Qxc5 17 Qb2 Qb4 18 Qxb4 Nxb4 19 Be7 Na6 20 Bxf8 Kxf8 21 f4 Nb4 22 Rfc1 c5 23 a3 Nc6 24 Rd1 Be6 25 Rd6 Ke7 26 Rb1 Na5 27 Rbd1 b6 28 h3 g6 29 Kh2 Rb8 30 g4 Rb7


31 Rxe6+ Kxe6 32 gxf5+ gxf5 33 Rd6+ Ke7 34 Rh6 Kf8 35 Rh5 Rf7 36 e6 Rf6 37 Rxh7 Rxe6 38 Rxa7 Rh6 39 Bf1 Rd6 40 h4 Rd2+ 41 Kg3 Ra2 42 h5 Rxa3 43 h6 Rxe3+ 44 Kh4 Kg8 45 Bh3 Rxh3+ 46 Kxh3 Nxc4 47 Kh4 Nd6 48 Kg5 Nf7+ 49 Kg6 Nh8+ 50 Kf6 Nf7 51 Rxf7 Resigns.

10643. L. Verkhovsky (C.N. 10640)

Vitaliy Yurchenko (Uhta, Russian Federation) notes the information about Verkhovsky on the back cover of a 2005 book by him:



Dan Scoones (Port Coquitlam, BC, Canada) draws attention to a webpage about Evgeny Gik with references to Verkhovsky having died and another Russian page featuring a photograph of Verkhovsky with Vladimir Lepeshkin.

10644. The BCM (C.N.s 10538, 10579 & 10613)


Below is a letter which we sent on 17 October 2017 by e-mail and registered post to the Editor of the BCM, with a copy to Mr Milan Dinic:

For publication, please

Dear Sirs,

The “clarification” on page 614 of the October 2017 BCM refers misleadingly to my e-mail reply of 29 September to Mr Dinic. As shown by my full text (C.N. 10613 at, the unsigned F.D. Yates article on pages 498-499 of the August 2017 BCM reproduced, word for word and without permission, an entire ChessBase feature of mine (about 700 words). No fewer than 93 lines of the two-page BCM article were written by me, i.e. about 80% of the whole BCM text.

My e-mail message nominated a charity to which I asked the BCM to make a substantial donation for misappropriating my work.

Yours faithfully,

Edward Winter

No reply, whether public or private, having been received, we simply summarize the facts (as shown in detail in C.N.s 10538, 10579 and 10613):

  • In the article about Yates in the August 2017 BCM the general introductory paragraph was lifted from Wikipedia, the other text was a copy-paste of our work, and the illustrative photograph supposedly of “Edward Lasker” was Emanuel Lasker.

  • The September 2017 BCM had a ‘correction’, but only concerning the Lasker photograph blunder. Moreover, the ‘correction’ was itself incorrect, stating that the author of the article was Pete Tamburro (who had no involvement in it).

  • On 28 September 2017 Mr Milan Dinic of the BCM sent us an e-mail message (nearly 600 words) which blamed faulty typesetting (the misuse of quotation marks) in the August 2017 article.

  • Our response the following day stressed how much of our work the BCM had lifted without permission, and we therefore asked the magazine to make a donation to charity.

  • No reply was received, but the October 2017 BCM published a ‘clarification’ which offered no clarity at all, contradicted Mr Dinic’s message to us and misrepresented our message to him.

  • Our letter of 17 October 2017 having been ignored, the BCM is still concealing from its readers its gross misappropriation of our work. The magazine’s own contribution to the two-page spread on Yates was virtually zero.

10645. Pillsbury blindfold game

Eduardo Bauzá Mercére (New York, NY, USA) sends this game from a 12-board blindfold display:

Harry Nelson Pillsbury – Edward Douglas Fawcett
Exeter, 24 April 1902
Ruy López

1 e4 e5 2 Nf3 Nc6 3 Bb5 Nf6 4 O-O Nxe4 5 d4 Be7 6 Qe2 Nd6 7 Bxc6 bxc6 8 dxe5 Nb7 9 Nc3 O-O 10 Re1 Re8 11 Qc4 Nc5 12 Ng5 Bxg5 13 Bxg5 Qxg5 14 Qxc5 Bb7 15 Qb4 Rab8 16 f4 Qg6 17 Qe4 Qxe4 18 Nxe4 Re7 19 Nc5 d5 20 exd6 Rxe1+ 21 Rxe1 Resigns.


Source: Western Times, 25 April 1902, page 12.

We add a photograph of E. Douglas Fawcett from page 464 of The Tatler, 5 September 1934:


10646. Steinitz and Chigorin (C.N. 10641)

Dan Scoones (Port Coquitlam, BC, Canada) writes:

‘The final quote from Chigorin in C.N. 10641 was on page 13 of Nikolai Grekov’s book Soviet Chess (New York, 1949):


The book’s translator was Theodore Reich.

Earlier the Chigorin quote had been given by Grekov on page 539 of his book Великий русский шахматист М. И. Чигорин (Moscow, 1939), again without any source:


“Нередко... ‘теоретическое’ – синоним шаблонного. Ибо что такое ‘теоретическое’ в шахматах, как не то, что можно встретить в учебниках и чего стараются придерживаться, раз не могут придумать чего-либо более сильного или равного, самобытного.”

I propose this translation:

“Often ... the ‘theoretical’ is synonymous with the stereotypical. For the ‘theoretical’ in chess is nothing other than what can be found in textbooks, which people try to follow because they cannot think of anything stronger, equally strong, or original.”

Chess Notes Archives


Copyright: Edward Winter. All rights reserved.